|
|
 |
|
Music
Richard Strauss
Lyrics
Lachmann
Book
by
Oscar Wilde
Director
Leah Hausman
Design
Vicki Mortimer
Lighting
Paul Pyant
Choreographer
Wayne McGregor
Translation
Tom Hammond
Performers
Salome
Cheryl Barker
Herodias
Sally Burgess
Jokanaan
Robert Hayward
Herod
John Graham-Hall
Narraboth
Andrew Rees
Herodias's
Page
Rebecca
de Pont Davies
|
|
| |
|
 |
 |
English
National Opera
London
Coliseum
19
October - 17 November 2005 |
 |
|
Late
nineteenth-century and early
twentieth-century art and
thought are suffused with
tortured and corrupted women.
Freud's investigations into
hysteria, and of Klimt's
murals for the various departments
of Vienna university are
just two examples of such
interests, much of which
was either explicitly or
implicity concerned with
women's sexuality.
It was in this late nineteenth-century
world of psychological probing
that Oscar Wilde wrote his
play Salomé
,
in French. In 1891 it was
banned in London, but was
very successfully performed
in Paris in 1894. In 1901
it was performed in Breslau
where the thirty-six year
old Strauss saw it. Between
1901 and the premiere of
the opera he based on the
Wilde play in 1905, Strauss
encountered a number of
difficulties not least some
singers who refused to sing
it on moral grounds.
Both Strauss's opera and
Wilde's play share their
intensity and sense of the
action being concentrated
in a single sweep. Neither
play nor opera has a break
(though I have attended
a performance which inserted
an interval after Narraboth's
death).
Wilde's play is like a dramatized
poem, Strauss's opera is
like a visually realized
symphonic poem. Wilde's
play is illumined by references
to the moon. Everything
is seen through the light
on the moon, and attitudes
to the moon become a kind
of metaphor for different
states of mind. The Page,
for instance, in innocence
says;
She
is like a princess who has
little white doves for feet.
You would fancy she was
dancing.
Salomé
says:
The
moon is cold and chaste.
I am sure she is a virgin,
she has a virgin's beauty.
Yes, she is a virgin. She
has never defiled herself.
She has never abandoned
herself to men, like the
other goddesses.
Herod
remarks:
The
moon has a strange look
tonight. Has she not a strange
look? She is like a madwoman,
a madwoman who is seeking
everywhere for lovers. She
is naked too. She is quite
naked. The clouds are seeking
to clothe her nakedness,
but she will not let them.
She shows herself naked
in the sky. She reels through
the clouds like a drunken
woman. She is like a madwoman
is she not?
On
the other hand, with almost
brutal realism, unreceptive
to the metaphorical perceptions
of others Herodias, Herod's
wife and in the Bible the
one who demands John the
Baptist's head on a platter,
says:
No,
the moon is like the moon,
that is all.
The
moon becomes the light through
which all the action is
seen. The play is set on
a hot and sultry evening.
Things are not seen as they
would be daylight. Fuelled
by wine, the characters
see the world through the
prism of the moon, and reality,
and by implication quotidian
morality, is suspended.
This is a dream-world rushing
towards a nightmare.
It was this concentration
that Strauss had to turn
into an opera. Wilde's words
are what re-iterate the
real and symbolic significance
of the moon. This was not
translatable into the music
of the opera, so Strauss
abandoned it, and instead
gave the work a symphonic
development and concentration.
The characteristic sound
of the music he composed
did service for the moon.
He used a massive orchestra
and a small array of obsessively
repeated musical themes,
such as the one attached
to John the Baptist and,
above all, the sequence
of falling fourths whose
third appearance is distorted
by augmentation. What makes
John the Baptist's first
physical appearance on the
stage (as opposed to his
voice from the dungeon)
so compelling is its glorious
and, by contrast, uncomplicated
major tonality. In contrast,
Salome's music is complex,
dissonant, angular and highly
chromatic. They are sonically
worlds apart, and the contrast
between the two musical
worlds runs through the
whole of the first part
of the opera.
Some critics have condemned
Strauss for trivializing
the complex psychology of
the story with merely dazzling
compositional virtuosity.
One even suggested that
the triple time in the final
exultation of Salome over
Jokanaan was so lush that
the Baptist's head might
be made of marzipan. Time
has left such comments high
and dry, and repeated exposure
to this exploration of female
psyche has proved perennially
compelling to audiences,
even if some are only concerned
with the vocal acrobatics
and physical appearance
of the woman singing Salome.
On every front Cheryl Barker's
performance is a triumph.
Vocally she conveyed Salome's
increasing lunacy, her gradual
divorce from reality. Physically
it was a pity that her movements
in the removing of her seven
veils was only rather tamely
erotic. Some years again
Josephine Barstow was able
to strip to a body-stocking
and fill the stage with
erotic movement. That production
was right not to underplay
this scene, and in the current
ENO production it is, but
only somewhat. This is a
pity, because Cheryl Barker
in BohËme showed herself
more than able to cavort
seductively; and in the
early scenes with John the
Baptist, and in the final
one with his severed head
in her hands, she performed
with such masterful gusto
both physically and vocally
that the relative tameness
of the Dance of the Seven
Veils seemed to timid by
comparison. Overall, however,
hers is a performance to
admire and relish, if the
latter is quite the word
for so horrific a dénouement.
Other singers matched Barker's
excellence in their roles.
Sally Burgess, using the
edge her voice has, made
Herodias the manipulating
queen the play and the opera
require. Hers was a terrifying
and electric performance.
Equally compelling, but
very different, was John
Graham Hall who with great
aplomb conveyed the lustful,
decadent, vacillating Herod
superbly. His particular
tenor-timbre seemed to suit
exactly the ruler, in turn
driven by lust to request
Salome's dance, by guilt
to try to make her change
her mind, and by disgust
to order her eventual execution
by being crushed to death
by soldiers' shields (something
which this production omitted).
Robert Hayward as Jokanaan
was also magnificent. His
voice and presence commanded
and overwhelmed. Jokanaan
is a role that needs volume
and grandeur, and this Hayward
had in full. His first emergence
from the underground cell
is one of the most compelling
moments in the production.
Another character is stands
outside the decadent triangle
of Herod, Herodias and Salome
is the Syrian captain of
the guard, Narraboth. On
the night I saw this production
Geraint Hylton replaced
Andrew Rees. Hylton's performance
was vocally rather strained
and his performance tentative
in comparison to the others
members of the cast, so
the opera took a while to
gain momentum.
Maybe the tentativeness
of the opening was due to
substitution nerves, so
at first Kwamé Ryan's
control of the score seemed
to lack direction and power.
But within only a few minutes
he had found just what the
opera needs, and he directed
with terrific power and
conviction. The success
of the performance is as
much due to his handling
of the orchestra and the
intelligent pacing of the
drama as anything else.
Leah Hausman's revival of
David Levaux's original
direction drove the action
forward and enabled the
singers to explore, with
the audience, the several
aspects of their roles.
The well-conceived stage-design
mixed symbolic decadence
(the crumbling building,
the detritus of a feast)
with touches of suggestive
realism. It works well,
though the moon is red not
white.
ENO's Salome
is a powerful evening. Acting
and singing are first-rate,
and the production does
more than justice to Strauss's
overwhelming score. Oscar
Wilde has Herod say, "Put
out the torches. I will
not look at things. I will
not suffer things to look
at me". After such
a performance the audience
might well echo his utterances.
Roderick
Swanston
|
|
|
|
 |
|
|
|
|